Discuss aristotle’s friendship philia
This chapter compares aristotle, hegel, and nietzsche on the topic of friendship, love (philia), and community walter kaufmann maintains that nietzsche retrieves aristotle’s view of noble friendship in the figure of the great soul (megalopsychos) because it includes relation to other in the self-relation, and thus appears to avoid the opposition between egoism and altruism that nietzsche. ² for good discussions on aristotle’s philia and modern friendship see j m cooper, ‘aristotle on friendship’, in a o rorty (ed), essays in aristotle’s ethics (berkeley and chosen to discuss lose little of their pertinence questions about the. By assuming that such ‘virtue friendship’ is the main focus of aristotle's attention, and that the broader use of the term philia is merely a concession to popular usage and secondary, it is easy to conclude that what aristotle is really interested in is what one calls friendship after all. March 2008 volume 3, number 1 a necessary conflict: eros and philia in a love relationship by sara protasi 1 i wasn’t a student of flavio’s long enough to profit from his academic teaching, since i was enrolled in the genoa phd program only one year.
Between advantage and virtue: aristotle’s theory of political friendship maintain that political friendship plays only a marginal role in aristotle’s discussion of philia and those claiming that political friendship is just a kind of advantage- it will be appropriate to discuss friendship, since friendship is a kind of excellence. Aristotle gives a pre-discussion about what he will discuss that is the 2713 i mentioned above in that description he refers to this subject matter as being about philia. Aristotle’s ‘nikomachean ethics: books viii and ix’ (350 bce) in books viii and ix of his treatise on ethics, aristotle provides a detailled account of friendship, it’s forms, virtue and social role up to date, his treatment of the subject matter is in all likelihood the most cited source. Although it is difficult to avoid the term “friendship” as a translation of “philia”, and this is an accurate term for the kind of relationship he is most interested in, we should bear in mind that he is discussing a wider range of phenomena than this translation might lead us to expect, for the greeks use the term, “philia”, to.
In book eight of nicomachean ethics, aristotle defines the three types of friendships that exist in the greek word philia (a broader definition of friendship than one might think), which are based off usefulness, pleasure, or goodness, the three reasons for liking something: friendships of utility, friendships of pleasure and complete friendships. “by friendship (philia) aristotle typically means the mutually acknowledged and reciprocal relation of good will and affection that exists among individuals who share an interest in each other on the basis of virtue, pleasure and utility” (sherman, 1987) in my opinion aristotle’s friendship of virtue is the most respectful relationship. A necessary conflict: eros and philia in a love relationship of friendship, assuming there is one, is very different compared not only to the when plato and aristotle spoke of eros and philia, the historical context in which they lived was quite different. Here we argue that an aristotelian influence may be found considering royce's notion of loyalty in conjunction with aristotle's notion of friendship (philia) in the nicomachean ethics. According to aristotle, friendship is a bond not only among the factions of the society but also among the individuals – the citizens of polis i will discuss the constituents of friendship in the nicomachean herodotus, for instance, continues to use philia to refer to guest-friendship as well as to private mutual affection most.
Study questions for aristotle's nicomachean ethics book viii book viii: friendship (partial) popular views and puzzles 1 what popular views concerning friendship (philia) does aristotle cite (summarize 1155a1-32 in your own words) socrates and his young friends discuss but do not resolve the question whether attraction between. Aristotle includes philia and philein – the verb that is cognate with philia and philos – in a discussion of the pathê or “emotions”4 the implicit logic is: “if you loved me as a friend those who most insist on the pragmatic and formal quality of ancient friendship tend to contrast it with the emotive basis of friendship today. Aristotle on friendship, justice, and the human good john andrew houston, purdue university abstract according to aristotle human beings are naturally rational and political animals, and what it is for them to flourish is to live a life of excellent rational activity in accordance with these dual aspects of their nature. Friendship, as understood here, is a distinctively personal relationship that is grounded in a concern on the part of each friend for the welfare of the other, for the other’s sake, and that involves some degree of intimacy.
Discuss aristotle’s friendship philia
Virtuous friendship (bks viii-ix) -there three kinds of friendly interaction—philia, which for aristotle is always grounded in some kind of commonality bringing some form of affection or good will this is what we might call friendship-useful friendship is a friendly interaction in which the common bond is utility or. A good introductory chapter describing how aristotle's nicomachean ethics identifies the qualities that attract people into friendship [philia] with each other, 'lovables' or phileta discuss this book. So we're almost through these two books are both about friendship~, but separated into viewing friendship as a smaller unit of political life.
- Thus, the domain of friendship and philia have good actions that don't come from an individual trying to make their own lives flourishing ones this is one kind of argument many people make against aristotle on friendship.
- Philia, while ordinarily translated as “friendship,” isn’t quite the same as our ordinary concept of friendship philia is a wider term than friendship it includes some relationships that we would not call friendships.
- This article examines aristotle’s use of the term philia as a basis for the analysis, the author employs the communicative component of this notion this allows us to consider friendship as a process, distinguishing it from everything else that cannot be identified as such this “residue” is.
'friendship' - philia - generally translated as 'friendship' includes what we would call friendship, but also includes any kind of affectionate regard, affection (as eg between family members), friendliness, or amiability. 22 jurnal hadhari 5 (1) (2013) 21 - 36 purpose of the friendship as presental by aristotle’s and al-ghazali to deeply understand this friendship. Add philia to your popflockcom topic list for future reference or share this resource on social media philia this article is written like a personal reflection or opinion essay that states a popflockcom resource editor's personal feelings about a topic. Aristotle’s discussion of the political form of friendship is particularly interesting because it provides a natural bridge between the ethics and the politics 13 aristotle taught that friendship could be, and most often is, found where individuals are united in a.